5 Steps to Playtest Homebrew Rules

Creating balanced homebrew RPG rules takes effort, but testing them doesn't have to be complicated. Follow these 5 steps to playtest effectively:

• Set Clear Goals: Decide what you’re testing (balance, clarity, speed) and write clear instructions.
• Run Basic Tests: Test each rule in isolation to see how it works.
• Collect Player Feedback: Use forms and group discussions to gather input.
• Refine Rules: Fix major issues first, then make smaller adjustments.
• Test Final Version: Check edge cases, compare to other games, and ensure everything works smoothly.

These steps help you identify issues early, refine your rules, and create a fun, balanced experience for players.

TTRPG Playtesting Best Practices

Step 1: Set Up Your Playtest

Plan your playtest carefully to collect useful feedback. Start by setting clear goals and creating easy-to-follow rules.

Define Your Goals

Decide what you want to learn from the playtest:

• Rule Balance: Assess how the rules affect the overall game balance.
• Game Speed: Determine if the rules influence how quickly or slowly the game plays.
• Rule Clarity: Ensure the rules are simple to understand.

Create Clear Instructions

Write down every rule in a way that’s easy for playtesters to understand. This helps them grasp the mechanics without confusion.

Step 2: Run Basic Tests

Start with initial testing rounds to identify any major problems. These early tests help you refine your rules and ensure they work as intended.

Test Each Rule on Its Own

Focus on one rule at a time to see its exact impact and figure out what needs tweaking. For instance, if you're introducing a new combat maneuver, run several combat scenarios using just that rule.

Here are some simple test ideas for individual rules:

• Combat rule: Simulate a basic fight between two characters.
• Skill check rule: Set up a straightforward challenge to test it.
• Resource management rule: Run a scenario focused on how resources are used.

Track and Analyze Results

Keep detailed records of your tests. Use a structured approach to gather both numbers and observations:

• Time spent: How long does it take to explain and use the rule?
• Success rates: How often is the rule applied correctly?
• Player confusion: When do players struggle, and why?
• Game impact: How does the rule affect the flow of the game?

Combine measurable data (like time and success rates) with notes on player reactions and engagement. This combination will guide your revisions in the next steps.

sbb-itb-b8b00a5

Step 3: Get Player Input

After running initial tests, the next step is to collect feedback from players. This input is crucial for spotting overlooked issues and fine-tuning your rules.

Use Feedback Forms

Design structured feedback forms to zero in on specific aspects of your rules. Include questions like:

• Rate the clarity of the rule on a scale of 1–5.
• How does the rule impact gameplay?
• Does the rule feel balanced and fair?
• How smoothly does the rule fit into the game?

Add open-ended questions to encourage detailed responses:

• "When was this rule most helpful?"
• "What challenges did you encounter using this rule?"
• "What changes would you suggest for this rule?"

Lead Group Discussions

Host post-session discussions to dive deeper into the feedback. Use prompts such as:

• General impressions of the game
• Specific interactions with the rule
• Surprises or unexpected issues
• Ideas for changes or improvements

Make sure everyone gets a chance to share their thoughts.

Review Feedback Patterns

Go through the feedback systematically to spot recurring themes. Here's a simple way to organize it:

Key patterns to document include:

• Issues that come up frequently
• Suggestions for improvement
• Rules that worked in unexpected ways
• Overall player satisfaction

Focus on consistent feedback across multiple playtests. These recurring points often highlight core problems that need fixing.

Step 4: Update the Rules

Use recurring feedback to fine-tune your homebrew rules while keeping the game balanced.

Fix Big Problems First

Start by addressing major issues that disrupt gameplay. Focus on problems that:

• Break essential game mechanics
• Create unfair advantages
• Cause frequent confusion
• Significantly slow down play

Here’s a simple way to prioritize fixes:

Make Small Changes

Tackle one change at a time and test its impact before introducing another. This method helps you:

• Pinpoint which changes improve gameplay
• Avoid unintended side effects
• Keep the system stable
• Measure the impact of each tweak

For example, if a combat ability feels overpowered, try reducing its effectiveness by 25% and observe the results.

Track Rule Changes

Keep a clear record of all updates using version control. For instance:

Version 1.2
- Reduced Mighty Strike damage from 3d6 to 2d6
- Added a 1-round cooldown to Healing Touch
- Clarified wording on Stealth checks

A detailed changelog should include the date, the specific changes made, the reasons behind them, and their effects. This documentation helps you:

• Roll back changes if needed
• Understand how your rules have evolved
• Share updates with players
• Spot trends in your rule adjustments

This log works hand-in-hand with your initial testing notes.

Step 5: Check Final Version

Now that you've refined your game using earlier tests and player feedback, it's time to ensure your rules are balanced and ready for gameplay.

Test Edge Cases

Evaluate how your game handles extreme scenarios that might arise during play. Here's a breakdown of what to test:

If your game includes a magic system, focus on these situations:

• Casting multiple spells in quick succession
• Combining magical effects in creative ways
• Using spells in unexpected scenarios
• Pushing the limits of power and resources

Compare these findings to established systems to see how your mechanics hold up under pressure.

Compare to Other Games

To gauge how your game measures up, compare its mechanics to those in well-known systems. Key areas to evaluate include:

• Combat Systems: Look at turn length, action economy, damage scaling, and how quickly combat resolves.
• Character Creation: Assess the flexibility of character builds, progression of power, customization options, and overall balance.
• Resource Management: Examine how resources are gained, used, and recovered, as well as their strategic importance.

This comparison helps you identify strengths and areas for improvement.

Define Success Measures

Set clear benchmarks to determine if your rules are ready. Use the table below to guide your evaluations:

Once your rules consistently meet these criteria, they’re ready for release. Keep a record of any minor issues for future updates.

Conclusion

Playtesting and gathering structured feedback are essential for refining homebrew rules into a seamless and engaging part of your game. By testing unusual scenarios and comparing outcomes to clear benchmarks, you can ensure your rules fit well and improve the overall experience. These approaches help turn playtests into meaningful feedback before finalizing your rules.

For more ideas and resources, check out the TTRPG Games Directory, which offers a wide range of tabletop RPGs and design tips.

Key Points:

• Collect feedback from a variety of players
• Test unusual scenarios to identify potential issues
• Use data to guide your adjustments
• Keep detailed records of all changes
• Stay informed about current design trends

Related posts

• How to Use Player Feedback for Better Homebrew Rules
• 5 Steps to Balance Racial Traits in TTRPGs
• How To Playtest Homebrew Rules
• Formatting Rulebooks for Homebrew RPGs